Refined Short Hills-style dining room with a walnut table, slate-blue chairs and tall windows overlooking a green lawn and late-autumn trees.

When Short Hills' Biggest Home Sales Closed in 2026

Two houses on Stewart Road in Short Hills closed at $5,000,000 each in June, two weeks apart. Number 83, built in 1963, closed on June 8. Number 127, a 2025 build, closed on June 22. Two days later, 882 S. Orange Ave. closed at $5,200,000, according to NJ.com's list for July 6 to 12. Those were three of the highest-priced sales in Essex County this year, and all three happened within 17 days of each other.

Fast forward to the most recent week of recorded sales. The most expensive home sold anywhere in Essex County during the week of Nov. 2 to 8 was 20 Pine Terrace E in Short Hills, a 1911 house that closed on Oct. 16 for $2,550,000, according to NJ.com's weekly roundup. It is still a Short Hills sale at the top of the county list, but it sits at about half the June figure.

In Millburn-Short Hills, the highest-priced sales close on a summer calendar. That means a buyer touring homes in late November is pricing them against comparable sales, or comps, from a market that has since moved to a lower price tier.

Eight closings at $4 million and up, all by early September

These figures come from the 18 weekly "most expensive homes sold in Essex County" lists that NJ.com published between June 12 and November 13, including the lists for Aug. 31 to Sept. 6, Sept. 7 to 13 and Sept. 28 to Oct. 4. Each list gives the closing date, year built and price. Eight Millburn Township sales on those lists reached $4 million or more, in this order:

  1. 83 Stewart Road, $5,000,000, closed June 8
  2. 127 Stewart Road, $5,000,000, closed June 22
  3. 882 S. Orange Ave., $5,200,000, closed June 24
  4. 6 Benson Court, $4,950,000, closed July 10
  5. 21 Harvey Drive, $4,925,000, closed Aug. 4
  6. 31 Forest Drive, $4,105,000, closed Aug. 14
  7. 2 Spenser Drive, $4,000,000, closed Aug. 21
  8. 19 Shelley Road, $4,725,851, closed Sept. 8

The houses on this list vary widely in age. 6 Benson Court was built in 1954 and 19 Shelley Road in 1953. 21 Harvey Drive dates from 2023, and 127 Stewart Road and 2 Spenser Drive were both built in 2025. Old houses and new construction closed in the same narrow window.

The next tier down follows the same calendar. Between $3 million and $4 million, the lists include:

  • June: 96 Westview Road at $3,740,000 on June 4, 3 Denman Court at $3,000,000 on June 10, and 126 Fairfield Drive at $3,500,000 on June 11
  • July: 38 Deer Path at $3,955,000 on July 17 and 2 Robert Drive at $3,800,000 on July 24
  • Late August: 171 Tennyson Drive, 100 Browning Road, 123 Highland Ave. and 11 Cayuga Way
  • Last in the tier: 2 Troy Drive, a 2017 house, at $3,320,000 on Sept. 14

After Sept. 14, no Millburn or Short Hills sale on these lists closed above $2,850,000.

A closing comes after the contract is signed, so the deals behind those June and August closings were agreed earlier still. On these lists, the township's 2026 sales above $3 million had all closed by mid-September.

The same streets, a different season

The pattern shows up clearly on single streets, because location stays the same and only the calendar changes.

Cross Gates had two sales on the lists. Number 8, built in 1937, closed on July 20 at $2,499,500. Number 14, built in 1941, closed on Sept. 29 at $2,850,000. On Hilltop Road, 49 Hilltop closed on June 25 at $2,825,000 and 19 Hilltop closed on Sept. 14 at $2,975,000. On these streets, fall sales held their value.

On streets where a much newer house sold in the summer, the spread is wider. Harvey Drive had 68 Harvey, built in 1971, close at $2,550,000 on July 22, and 21 Harvey, built in 2023, close at $4,925,000 on Aug. 4. On Tennyson Drive, the 1954 house at number 105 closed at $2,350,000 in July, and the 2013 house at number 171 closed at $3,965,000 in August. Denman Court had three sales on the lists, and each closed lower than the one before. Number 3 closed at $3,000,000 in June, number 2 at $2,950,000 in August, and number 14, built in 1973, at $2,450,000 in mid-September.

Our earlier post on a Sunset Drive teardown looked at what the land under a house is worth. These sales point to a second factor. On Harvey Drive and Tennyson Drive, the newer house set the higher summer price, and a summer comp from a street like that may describe a different kind of house than anything for sale there this fall.

What closed in October

Here are the Millburn and Short Hills sales that closed in October and appeared on the lists for Oct. 19 to 25 and Nov. 2 to 8:

  • 39 Mechanic Street, Millburn, built 1952: $1,888,800, closed Oct. 5
  • 9 Sylvan Way, Short Hills, built 2012: $2,000,000, closed Oct. 8
  • 47 Dorison Drive, Short Hills, built 1960: $2,780,500, closed Oct. 8
  • 27A Willow Street, Millburn, built 2025: $1,200,000, closed Oct. 13
  • 904 Ridgewood Road, Millburn, built 1924: $1,040,000, closed Oct. 15
  • 67 Myrtle Ave., Millburn: $2,300,000, closed Oct. 16
  • 20 Pine Terrace E, Short Hills: $2,550,000, closed Oct. 16

Late September looked much the same. 106 Short Hills Ave., built in 1893, closed at $1,875,000, and 36 Kean Road closed at $2,600,000. 38 Farview Road in Millburn closed at $2,668,650.

Millburn Township kept producing the county's top sale. In 10 of the 18 weekly lists, the most expensive Essex County sale was in Short Hills or Millburn. That includes three of the four lists published from Oct. 23 through Nov. 13. Livingston led two of the fall weeks, Oct. 5 to 11 and Oct. 26 to Nov. 1. In the weeks Short Hills led this fall, its top sale was well below the June level.

The county ran on the same clock

Essex County as a whole followed a similar curve, though at much lower prices. NJ.com's lists also report each week's county-wide average sale price, based on the week the deed was recorded:

  • Summer weeks: $900,695 for July 6 to 12 and $983,748 for Sept. 7 to 13
  • Fall weeks: $761,301 for Oct. 12 to 18, $756,670 for Oct. 19 to 25, $755,643 for Oct. 26 to Nov. 1, and $760,412 for Nov. 2 to 8

The New Jersey REALTORS October report for Essex County single-family homes shows the market loosening slightly compared with a year earlier.

Essex County single-family October 2026 October 2025
Closings 233 280
Percent of list price received 106.7% 108.3%
Homes for sale 772 697
Months of supply 2.8 2.5

The full year still looks strong. Through October, the county's median single-family price was $808,000, up from $765,000 in the same period of 2025, and sellers received 109.4% of list price on average. So a buyer this fall has somewhat more homes to choose from and slightly less pressure to bid over asking than a year ago, in a county where prices are still rising over the year.

Reading summer comps at a November showing

When a Short Hills listing comes with comps above $4 million in 2026, every one of those comps closed between June 8 and Sept. 8. Each is a real sale, and each reflects a contract agreed before the summer was over. Three of the eight were houses built in 2023 or 2025.

For a buyer comparing towns this month, the most useful approach is to sort the comps by closing month as well as by street. The October group of 47 Dorison, 20 Pine Terrace E, 67 Myrtle and 39 Mechanic shows what the market is paying right now for the houses actually for sale. The June group of Stewart Road, S. Orange Ave. and Westview Road shows the ceiling that the spring market set. A seller deciding between listing in winter and waiting for spring is weighing that same calendar.

Our recent sales page and Millburn-Short Hills neighborhood guide cover individual streets in more detail.

If you are weighing a Short Hills or Millburn home this winter and want comps sorted by closing month, street and age of house, Judith Daniels Real Estate Team can go through this year's sales with you. Request a complimentary market consultation and we will show you which 2026 sales match the house you are considering.

Work With Us

Known for exceptional client service, sharp market insight, and a distinguished record of success, the team specializes in luxury real estate and delivers a strategic, seamless, and consistently elevated experience.

Follow Us on Instagram